I believe that the Asian species Tofi describes,
Elephantopus scaber is considered the "type" of the genus, and I imagined that it must look more like an elephant's foot than the U.S. species.
Looking at photos of
E. scaber, the resemblance isn't striking, but then again, I haven't ever examined an actual elephant's foot up close...
¯\_(ツ)_/¯